Back

Login

there's nothing actually going on in harry potter that you couldn't also apply to 99% of fantasy fare---it's not that those criticisms are wrong, they're just not unique. except for the house elf stuff, which was a hilariously obvious instance of "ah shit I just invented an oppressed underclass but I don't want this book series to become about this oppressed underclass ah fuck retcon it so that everything's okay". except (1) hey jkr why don't you wanna write stories about oppressed underclasses, huh? (2) maybe you shoulda thought about the implications of this when you casually created an oppressed underclass and (3) our terf-y friend probably picked the worst way out of it, which was "actually they *enjoy* being oppressed!! let's all laugh at the character who's having the obvious audience reaction to this". Instead, consider if it turns out that house elves are happy to work for, say, a beer at the end of the day, and hermione's like "no you have to be paid in Money, like real People do", and someone sat her down and was like "listen, who are you to say what's most important to people". except, you know, that's a critique of capitalism and neoliberalism so of course terfessa would never write such a thing